Birkin vs Kelly: The Definitive Hermès Bag Comparison

The Hermès Birkin and Kelly are two of the most iconic handbags in the world. While both are timeless investments, they serve different needs and styles. This guide breaks down their differences in design, size, function, and value to help you choose the right one for you.

Origins of the Hermès Birkin and Kelly

The Story Behind the Birkin Bag

Born from a chance encounter between Jane Birkin and Hermès CEO Jean-Louis Dumas in 1984, the Birkin was designed to be spacious, practical, and effortlessly chic.

The History of the Kelly Bag

Originally called the Sac à Dépêches, the Kelly gained fame when Princess Grace Kelly used it to shield her pregnancy from paparazzi in 1956. It was later renamed in her honour.

Birkin vs Kelly – At a Glance

Feature Birkin Kelly
Handles Two top handles One top handle, one shoulder strap
Closure Open flap with turn-lock (usually left open) Flap with turn-lock and two side straps
Formality Casual to semi-formal Formal, structured look
Best for Everyday use, travel Elegant events, polished daily wear

Size Options

Popular Birkin Sizes – 25, 30, 35, 40

The Birkin comes in a range of sizes. Birkin 25 is compact and trendy, while Birkin 30 and 35 offer versatility. The 40 is ideal for travel or work.

Kelly Sizes – Retourne vs Sellier Explained

Kelly bags are available in structured Sellier or softer Retourne styles. Sizes range from the mini Kelly 20 to the classic Kelly 28 and larger.

Functionality and Lifestyle Fit

The Birkin's open design makes it easier to access your essentials on the go, but it lacks a shoulder strap. The Kelly, with its crossbody option and secure closure, is ideal for hands-free elegance.

Investment Value and Resale

Both the Birkin and Kelly are strong investment pieces with exceptional resale value. Limited colours, rare leathers, and desirable sizes (such as Kelly 25) often appreciate over time.

Which Hermès Bag Suits You Best?

If you’re looking for something structured, elegant, and refined, go for the Kelly. Prefer a relaxed, roomy carryall? The Birkin is your match. Both are icons—you simply can’t go wrong.

Frequently Asked Questions

Which is more expensive – the Birkin or Kelly?

Prices vary depending on size, leather, and rarity. Generally, Birkins command a slightly higher price, especially in larger sizes.

Which is easier to buy?

Both are notoriously hard to get from Hermès boutiques without a strong purchase history. Preloved markets offer a more accessible option.

Which is the better investment?

Both hold their value, but smaller sizes like the Birkin 25 and Kelly 25 tend to see the strongest returns.

Still Deciding Between a Birkin or Kelly?

Explore our curated collection of preloved Hermès Birkin bags and preloved Hermès Kelly bags, hand-selected for luxury collectors like you.